When Conflict Destroys a Business: Why the Creative Industries Need Mediation?

No items found.

Fidana Alieva

No items found.

COMMERCIAL MEDIATION · DEAL MEDIATION · CREATIVE INDUSTRIES

Every successful creative project has at least two stories behind its creation. The first is the story of an idea, talent, ambition, creativity and entrepreneurial courage. The story of how something that initially existed only in the imagination of a few people becomes a recognisable brand, an international business and a commercially successful project. The second is the story of the agreements between the people who decided to turn that idea into a business. The story of partnership, the allocation of roles, investment, responsibility, control and joint decision-making. And while the first story often becomes a source of admiration, the second can sometimes become the reason for a project's downfall. You can create a brand recognised around the world, attract significant investment, bring together a talented team and enter international markets. But can all of this be preserved if the people who built the business together are no longer able to agree on its present and future?

When a project involves an original idea, intellectual property, investment, reputation, the ambitions of its founders and the interests of commercial partners, a conflict rarely remains simply a dispute between two parties. It can put at risk the value that has taken years to create.

This year, the conflict surrounding the French fashion brand #Coperni has attracted the industry's attention. Serious disagreements emerged between its founders and Tomorrow Ltd, which acted as the brand's majority shareholder and distributor. In June, Coperni SAS entered judicial restructuring proceedings, and in November the founders announced the cessation of the company's operations. The parties publicly presented different positions regarding the causes and circumstances of the conflict. There is no information available regarding whether they engaged in mediation or what negotiation tools they used.

However, the situation itself makes us reflect on how vulnerable even a successful international project can become when deep disagreements arise between its key stakeholders.

Why Is the Creative Business Particularly Vulnerable to Conflict?

In creative projects, business and the personal identity of their founders are often closely intertwined. For one partner, a brand may primarily be a creative endeavour, an expression of their artistic vision and professional identity. For another, it may be an investment asset that should generate returns and develop according to a particular business model. Add to this intellectual property, profit distribution, management powers, licensing, international distribution, investment and liability.

The result is a complex system of interdependencies in which a conflict between several key stakeholders can affect employees, contractors, suppliers and commercial partners, potentially putting the entire project at risk. At the same time, the parties do not always realise that, in the course of a conflict, they may lose far more than they are trying to protect. This is why the creative industries need not only mediation as a means of resolving existing disputes, but also a culture of professional conflict management.

Why Can Elements of Transformative Mediation Be Particularly Useful in Such Conflicts?

In commercial disputes, the main focus is often on reaching a specific agreement: the allocation of assets, financial compensation, exit arrangements or the redistribution of management powers. However, behind legal and financial disagreements between co-founders and key business partners, there are often deeper issues: loss of trust, fundamentally different visions of the business, a sense of injustice, communication breakdown and an inability to hear one another. In such situations, elements of transformative mediation can be particularly effective. It is based on two important processes:

1. Restoring the parties' ability to make their own decisions, with the mediator helping participants better understand their interests, recognise their needs, assess risks and possible future scenarios, and regain a sense of control over the situation.

2. Developing mutual understanding, which means creating an opportunity to hear the other party, understand their concerns, motivations and vision of the future, even if the parties continue to disagree substantially.

Why does this matter? Because sometimes entrepreneurs need more than simply agreeing on who gets what when leaving a business. They need to understand what happened to their partnership, what each of them genuinely wants and what opportunities remain for their future. At the same time, I do not consider the transformative approach to be universal or the only appropriate model for all commercial disputes. Depending on the circumstances, other mediation models may also be effective, as may a combination of different approaches and tools. For me, as a mediator, it is essential to see not only the dispute that needs to be resolved, but also the people, relationships and business value behind it.

A Few Observations from My Practice

In my practice, I have handled several cases involving mediation and negotiations in the creative industries. I would like to share two examples that particularly illustrate why working with the parties' interests and communication is so important.

In one case, two partners who had once jointly established an art gallery could no longer continue working together, but they were also unable to reach an agreement on their separation independently. In this situation, it was important not simply to determine the terms of the business separation. We worked extensively with the parties' interests, their views of the future, their personal and professional plans, and assessed the risks associated with different scenarios. This made it possible to approach the separation not as a defeat for either party, but as a decision-making processt hat needed to take into account both partners' interests, their future professional activities and the consequences of each possible scenario.

In another case, the situation was considerably more complex: there was a significant power imbalance between the co-founders of a company who had created a well-known brand, and the parties had fundamentally different views on how the business should be managed and how the project should develop. The dispute concerned not only the partnership itself, but also a broader range of property and intellectual property rights: copyright, the division of corporate assets, and rights to products created and released under the brand. An additional obstacle was the position of one party's lawyer, who actively encouraged their client to pursue litigation and obstructed direct communication between the parties.Yet the opportunity for direct dialogue within the mediation process proved particularly important.

This case once again reminded me how important it is to prevent a conflict from turning entirely into a confrontation between opposing legal positions. Legal representation is essential for representing the parties' interests and assessing the consequences of their decisions. However, it should not exclude the possibility of direct communication between the parties, provided such communication is possible and safe for those involved.

Deal Mediation: When Mediator Is Needed Before a Dispute Arises

There is another aspect that, in my view, does not receive sufficient attention, particularly in international projects. This is deal mediation, which involves the participation of a mediator in the preparation and structuring of transactions, negotiations between prospective business partners and the development of agreements. The larger the project and the greater the number of stakeholders involved, the higher the cost of poorly designed agreements. When establishing a joint business, investment project, international brand or partnership, it is important to discuss in advance not only equity distribution and financial obligations, but also potential scenarios of disagreement, for example:

  • How will decisions be made if the parties fundamentally disagree about the future of the project?
  • What happens if one partner wants to leave the business?
  • How will the value of a share be assessed?
  • How will intellectual property issues be addressed?
  • How will the parties respond to a change of shareholder or investor?
  • What mechanisms can prevent management deadlock?

A mediator can help the parties identify potential areas of tension, explore their interests and expectations, assess the risks associated with different scenarios and develop agreements that take into account the future development of their relationship. Essentially, this represents a shift from reactive dispute resolution to proactive conflict management. That is why I believe that involving a mediator at the stage of preparing complex international transactions can be no less important than engaging one when a dispute has already arisen.

A Mediation Clause Is Not a Formality, but Part of the Architecture of an International Partnership

Mediation clauses are becoming a natural part of international commercial contracts, particularly in projects involving multiple investors, founders and commercial partners. However, including a mediation clause in international contracts should not be treated as a mere formality, but rather as a carefully designed dispute resolution mechanism. It is important to agree in advance on the procedure for appointing a mediator, the timelines, language and venue of the mediation, the applicable rules and the relationship between mediation and other methods of legal protection. This does not guarantee that conflicts will never arise. But it allows the parties to agree, befored isagreements emerge, on how they will address them.

Consider Mediation Before a Conflict Arises

Hopefully,  entrepreneurs, investors, founders of creative projects and their legal advisers will take a broader view of mediation. A mediator can be valuable:

  • when establishing a joint business and negotiating investment agreements;
  • in negotiations between founders, investors and commercial partners;
  • when disagreements arise over business management and development;
  • when restructuring a partnership;
  • when one of the co-founders exits a project;
  • when resolving complex international commercial disputes.

Mediation does not always mean preserving a partnership. Sometimes the best solution is to help people part ways while preserving the value they have created and their ability to move forward. But sometimes, during mediation, the parties discover solutions they had not even considered initially. And instead of simply bringing a conflict to an end, they may find an opportunity to create something new and even more promising.

Perhaps the main question to ask in disputes of this kind is not "How do we win?" but "How do we preserve the value we have created?" I believe that this shift in mindset is precisely where the wider adoption of mediation in the creative industries and international business should begin, and perhaps then there will be no losers.

‍